SC Politics

National ‘Conservative’ Group Grades South Carolina Lawmakers

Spoiler alert: South Carolina is still the “most liberal Republican legislature in America …”

To make clear at the outset, the word “conservative” is in baby quotes in that headline not because I am necessarily impugning any particular organization – or the ratings /rankings it releases or the politicians it is grading. I just think this word – “conservative” – has become so diluted due to excessive, erroneous self-adhesion that it no longer means much of anything.

For example, “Republicans” run South Carolina … but do they really?

Every time I turn around, GOP rule in the Palmetto State is careening further leftward fiscally via mindless government growth and escalating crony capitalism. Or … worse.

Still, we are told this is the party of “limited government.” Really? Could have fooled me.

It would be one thing if this massive, ongoing taxpayer investment was producing positive outcomes for the people. Unfortunately, everything governor Henry McMaster and his “Republican” allies touch – public safety, infrastructure, energyeducationtaxesspending and employment – turns to scheisse.

Accordingly, I routinely put the GOP partisan identifier – another victim of excessive, erroneous self-adhesion – in baby quotes to alert my readers that when it comes to the “Republican” brand, caveat emptor.



Of course, all of these “Republicans” in South Carolina are also “conservatives.” Even state senator Luke Rankin – who last year was ranked as the most liberal GOP member of the most liberal GOP legislature in America – brands himself as a “conservative Republican.”

His ranking aside, Rankin is more responsible than any other lawmaker for the biggest crony capitalist debacle in the history of the state … the NukeGate fiasco which set South Carolina citizens and taxpayers back by an estimated $10 billion (and counting).

But he is a “conservative?”

Sheesh …

Anyway, this week the American Conservative Union Foundation (ACUF) – which is best known for hosting the annual Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) – released its annual ratings for members of state legislatures across the nation.

How did South Carolina lawmakers fare? Not well … which is somewhat surprising considering we were told 2021 was going to be “different” after the GOP stormed to near-supermajorities in both chambers following the 2020 election.

Sadly, only one member of either chamber – state representative Jonathon Hill of Townville – received a perfect 100 percent score from the group in 2020. Only two other lawmakers – Stewart Jones of Laurens and Josiah Magnuson of Campobello – scored higher than 90 percent.

Of the 170 members of the legislature, only 16 scored higher than 80 percent. And as for lawmakers’ “lifetime” ratings, an even smaller number – fourteen – scored higher than 80 percent.

(Click to view)

(Via: Columbia S.C. Photographers Travis Bell)

Also, only one ranking “Republican” – Senate majority leader Shane Massey (above) of Edgefield – scored higher than eighty percent in either category, demonstrating the extent to which those who pull the levers of power in the South Carolina capital are virtually indistinguishable from their Democratic colleagues.

Powerful Senate finance committee chairman Hugh Leatherman of Florence, for example, had a lifetime score of 31 percent. That is identical to the score posted by Rankin, who leads the influential judiciary committee. Only one “Republican” – former senator Paul Campbell of Charleston – scored lower, at 30 percent.

Senate president Harvey Peeler fared modestly better at 53 percent, while the leader of the S.C. House – speaker Jay Lucas – received an anemic 49 percent rating.

All told, the S.C. General Assembly ranked No. 34 out of the fifty state legislatures in terms of its votes – which once again made it the most liberal GOP-controlled legislature in America (since the ACU has been keeping tabs, anyway).

Yet this is supposed to be the “reddest state in America?”

Again, please …

If I have said it once, I have said it a million times: The sooner citizens stop looking at political labels – and start looking at votes their “leaders” cast (and the outcomes produced by those tallies) – the sooner they might start getting the sort of government they deserve.

To view the ACUF ratings for yourself, click here.



(Via: FITSNews)

Will Folks is the founding editor of the news outlet you are currently reading. Prior to founding FITSNews, he served as press secretary to the governor of South Carolina. He lives in the Midlands region of the state with his wife and seven children. And yes, he has LOTS of hats (including that 2010 San Francisco Giants’ World Series lid pictured above).



Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our articles? Or an issue you’d like to address proactively? We have an open microphone policy! Submit your letter to the editor (or guest column) via email HERE. Got a tip for a story? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question or a glitch to report? CLICK HERE.


Get our newsletter by clicking here …


BANNER: Travis Bell Columbia SC Photographers


Get our newsletter by clicking here …


Related posts

SC Politics

Former Midlands GOP Chairman Arrested

Will Folks
SC Politics

South Carolina Democrats Are Bailing On Heather Bauer

Will Folks
SC Politics

South Carolina Runoff Races: Nobody Voted


Leave a Comment