Image default
State House

South Carolina Democrats Finally ‘Win’ A Statewide Office

GOP governor Henry McMaster installs a Democrat as comptroller general …

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

South Carolina Democrats haven’t won a statewide election since 2006 –  when Jim Rex narrowly defeated Karen Floyd in the race for state superintendent of education. Rex edged Floyd by 455 votes – the narrowest margin of victory in a statewide election in South Carolina history.

Rex has since bolted the Democratic party, incidentally … making him not unlike broad swaths of Palmetto State voters.

No Democrat has won a top-of-the-ticket race in South Carolina this millennium. The last person to do it? The late Fritz Hollings, who defeated former GOP congressman Bob Inglis to win his final term in the U.S. Senate in 1998.

Democrats have gotten pounded at the statewide level ever since … losing by bigger and bigger margins each election cycle.

After a “red storm” in 2020, they got crushed harder than ever in 2022 … losing every statewide election and becoming a “superminority” in the S.C. House of Representatives. The party also became an effective “superminority” in the State Senate when senator Mia McLeod announced she was becoming an independent in January of this year.

Democrats control just one of seven congressional districts, too … and we learned a lot earlier this month about the corrupt reason why that is the case.

How have “Republicans” wielded their absolute power? Absolutely atrociously …



For those of you who haven’t been paying attention, the state’s economy is not moving in the right direction (see here and here). Nor are its schools (see here). Nor are its communities (see here). And nor is its court system (see here).

All of these deplorable outcomes have been “achieved” despite gargantuan new taxpayer investments … expenditures which have fueled the perpetuation of an antiquated, corrupt and duplicative bureaucracy which does a multitude of things government has no business doing (like running universitiespower companiesports and hospitals, etc.).

In addition to these incessant incursions on the free market, GOP lawmakers have embraced unchecked crony capitalism … corporate welfare which diverts money from the individuals and small businesses which drive job creation in South Carolina.

Or should be driving it …

Owing to these policies, the SCGOP-controlled General Assembly has been ranked as the most liberal “Republican-controlled” state legislature in America three years running.

In keeping with this theme of “Republican” politicians governing as Democrats, GOP governor Henry McMaster – a career politician has done nothing but perpetuate South Carolina’s failed status quo since taking office in 2017 – made a surprising appointment last week.

On Friday, McMaster tapped veteran S.C. Department of Administration (SCDOA) budget analyst Brian J. Gaines to act as interim comptroller general. This choice fell to the governor after state lawmakers were unable to agree on a replacement for ousted GOP comptroller general Richard Eckstrom. Gaines will hold the role until lawmakers agree to pick a replacement for the rest of Eckstrom’s unexpired term – which runs through January 2027.

(Click to View)

Brian J. Gaines takes the oath of office as interim comptroller general of South Carolina (Governor’s Office)

Eckstrom had held this office since 2001, but was pushed out by legislators last month after he acknowledged a $3.5 billion “anomaly” in the state’s general fund budget.

Is Gaines a Republican? While I would argue the primary issue here is whether he can count … this post isn’t just about running the state’s books. As interim comptroller general, Gaines now has a seat on the powerful S.C. State Fiscal Accountability Authority (SCSFFA) – which oversees a broad range of key fiscal duties including approving bond issuances, insurance payouts and agency head salaries, among other items.

So … is Gaines a Republican? (You know, again, to the extent that seems to matter in South Carolina).

No, he is not. Election records indicate Gaines voted in Democratic primaries in 2016, 2018 and 2022. Since 2008, he has never voted in a Republican primary.

South Carolina Democrats wasted little time in trolling McMaster for his choice, mocking Eckstrom for his $3.5 billion error and crediting the governor for appointing someone to replace him who was not “a known Republican …”

Former SCDP chairman Trav Robertson got into the mix, too.

“Thank you senator Larry Grooms and Governor McMaster for appointing Brian Gaines Comptroller General!” Robertson tweeted. “He will do a magnificent job.”

Republican lawmakers – including several senators – were livid at the selection.

“The General Assembly leaves town for a day and Henry starts turning the state over to liberal Democrats,” one lawmaker told me confidentially, referring to the abbreviated adjournment of the 2023 legislative session last Thursday afternoon.

Meanwhile a GOP statewide official slammed McMaster’s comptroller choice as “bunk.”

In fairness, GOP legislators had their chance … and simply couldn’t resolve their internal spitball fight. And sadly the S.C. Senate’s preferred candidate for the post – career bureaucrat Mike Shealy – was a twenty-year lieutenant of über-liberal Senate leader Hugh Leatherman, a former Democrat who never really abandoned his big government leanings.

Who knows … maybe Gaines will make a great comptroller (it’s certainly hard to imagine him doing any worse than a guy who misplaced $3.5 billion). And maybe he will be a taxpayer watchdog on the SCSFFA – voting in lockstep with fiscal conservative Curtis Loftis to protect the people’s investment in their ostensibly limited government.

For now, though, his appointment is yet another reminder that “GOP rule” in the Palmetto State isn’t all it’s cracked up to be …



Will Folks on phone
Will Folks (Brett Flashnick)

Will Folks is the founding editor of the news outlet you are currently reading. Prior to founding FITSNews, he served as press secretary to the governor of South Carolina. He lives in the Midlands region of the state with his wife and seven children.



Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our articles? Or an issue you’d like to address proactively? We have an open microphone policy! Submit your letter to the editor (or guest column) via email HERE. Got a tip for a story? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question or a glitch to report? CLICK HERE.


Get our newsletter by clicking here ...


Related posts

State House

South Carolina Senators Seek To Oust Luke Rankin As Judiciary Chairman

Will Folks
State House

South Carolina Senate Staffer Passes Away

State House

‘This Is Not A Conservative Budget’: SC Freedom Caucus Rejects Pork Barrel Spending

Dylan Nolan


Willy May 15, 2023 at 1:06 pm

Thank you Governor McMaster.
As a card carrying member of the GOP I am glad we are giving away constitutional offices to Democrats.
I am glad the Democrat you chose will hire Left-Wing activist and further the cause of the hard Left.
Yes, I am tired of belonging to a party that pretends to be conservative.
I like honesty-let the Dems rule.

CEO of Antifa May 15, 2023 at 1:45 pm

Oh noes, the hard Left! Someone save us from the evil Democrat agenda of… slight improvements to barely functioning programs?

Sometimes you just have to stop and appreciate how insane the right has become on, well… everything.

Thompson2 May 15, 2023 at 1:12 pm

Our legislature is Left of center. Our governor appoints Democrats to state wides offices. I am feeling cheated

DJT May 15, 2023 at 1:15 pm

SC Republicans are the best politicians the SC Democrats can imagine. No conservative values, no conservative actions, just conservative rhetoric.

Facts May 15, 2023 at 1:19 pm

Well, it is near impossible to find a competent Republican politician these days.

Mister Ed's Vet May 15, 2023 at 1:46 pm

Just ask them how vaccines work and you’ll lose faith in basic science education in public schools.

Simpy May 15, 2023 at 1:57 pm

McMaster is feeling the white guilt from his fraternity days. White guilt in a republican governor is a powerful thing. Mia for Supreme Court!

Mark May 15, 2023 at 5:24 pm

I can’t see Governors James Edwards, Carol Campbell or David Beasley appointing a democrat to a state wide office. The guy will hire Democrats only and it will end ups like the Dept of Ed – the place is run by democrats no matter who wins the election.
Republicans should appoint Republicans, said everyone.

jane goodall May 16, 2023 at 1:46 pm

maybe he’ll run it like SCstate univ zoo


Leave a Comment