Burying The Lede: Winthrop Poll’s White Supremacy Question

Southern blacks prefer white supremacists and neo-Nazis more than southern whites?

We wrote earlier (much to our chagrin) on the latest Winthrop Poll, which delved into southerners’ attitudes on race relations.

It now appears we may have buried the lede in our coverage …

As noted yesterday, the Winthrop Poll surveyed more than 830 people in eleven southern states between October 22 and November 5 of this year.  Dialing a mix of land lines and cell phones, its poll operators asked respondents – black and white – to share their “feelings toward some of our political leaders and other people or groups who are in the news these days.”

“I’ll read the name of a person and I’d like you to rate that person using something we call the feeling thermometer,” poll operators asked.

Hmmm …. “feeling thermometer?”

How does this “feeling thermometer” work?

“Ratings between 50 degrees and 100 degrees mean that you feel favorable and warm toward the person or group,” the operators continued.  “Ratings between 0 degrees and 50 degrees mean that you don’t feel favorable toward the person or group and that you don’t care too much for them.”

Sounds simple enough …

“You would rate the person or group at the 50 degree mark if you don’t feel particularly warm or cold toward the person or group,” operators added.

Right. Okay. We get it …

What don’t we get?  The results.

We didn’t even notice it in our initial report, but Winthrop pollsters found that black southerners apparently have a greater affinity for white supremacists and neo-Nazis than white southerners.  In the case of neo-Nazis, the Winthrop data revealed black southerners were actually twice as likely to feel “warmly” about this group than their white counterparts.

Wait … what?

No, this is not a Clayton Bigsby joke (one of our favorite Dave Chappelle skits from the early 2000s).  This is ostensibly real data – although as we’ve said repeatedly we take Winthrop polling with a grain of salt.

More so now than ever, it would appear.

Seriously, take a look …

(Click to view)

(Via: Winthrop Poll)

That’s right … according to this survey, white southerners reported having a 6.6 “temperature” toward white supremacists and a 3.4 “temperature” toward neo-Nazis.  Meaning they don’t feel warmly toward either group at all.

Shockingly, though, black respondents had a 7.9 “temperature” toward both white supremacists and neo-Nazis.

What in the world? 

Here’s the explanation offered by the pollsters …

While African Americans having slightly higher feeling thermometer scores for white supremacists and neo-nazis could simply be statistical noise, there is also a significant possibility that the low score for whites is due to “social desirability,” that is, the propensity to give answers to some controversial questions in a way that won’t make the respondent “look bad.” This fascinating artifact of the data deserves further research.

Translation?  White people in the south are not only racist … they’re dishonest.

“If I’m reading that right, (pollsters) think white people are more racist … they just won’t admit it to a pollster,” one source confused by the results told us.

Indeed …

Of course this wouldn’t explain why eight percent of black voters in the south allegedly feel warmly about white supremacists and neo-Nazis – numbers that are well outside this survey’s margin of error.

“Statistical noise?”

Bottom line?  We think the Winthrop Poll needs to recalibrate its “feeling thermometer.”  Or risk its credibility being further impugned.



Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our stories? Please feel free to submit your own guest column or letter to the editor via-email HERE. Got a tip for us? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question? CLICK HERE. Want to support what we’re doing? SUBSCRIBE HERE.

Banner: iStock

Related posts


Lowcountry Government Drama: Federal Lawsuit Filed

Will Folks

Missing Macaque Captured

Will Folks

Missing Macaque Wanders Walterboro

Will Folks

Leave a Comment