4Q 2018: Same Data, Different Spin

Where has the economy been and where is going? It all depends on who you ask …

The American economy expanded at a 2.6 percent clip during the fourth quarter of 2018, according to initial data released this week by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA).   Assuming this number holds, it would mean economic growth for the previous year clocked in either right above or just below the elusive 3.0 percent mark, depending on the metric you choose to use.

Why does this number matter? Because gross domestic product (GDP) in the United States has not expanded at a three percent clip since 2005 – the first year of former president George W. Bush’s second term in office. It hasn’t eclipsed the four percent threshold since 2000 – former U.S. president Bill Clinton’s final year in office. 

By contrast, growth exceeded five percent in twelve out of thirty years from 1950-1980.  And it exceeded four percent in seventeen out of those thirty years.

Clearly the era of obscenely big government – along with the escalating, unsustainable debt it is producing – is not serving our nation well.

According to the latest BEA data (.pdf), current estimates for 2018 have real GDP expanding by 2.9 percent last year from 2017’s 2.2 percent print. Measured from the fourth quarter of 2017 to the fourth quarter of 2018, real GDP grew at a 3.1 percent clip compared to a 2.5 percent growth rate the previous year.

Not surprisingly, different mainstream media outlets viewed this data … differently.

Fox News – typically staunch supporters of U.S. president Donald Trumptrumpeted the news with the headline “Annual economic growth hits three percent, defying predictions of Trump critics.” The outlet then proceeded to mock various liberal economists and media outlets that predicted slower growth for 2018.

Meanwhile, Russian-owned Sputnik took a decidedly different, more forward-looking tone with its headline: “Sounding The Alarm: US’ 2018 GDP Report Highlights Trend in Economic Slowdown.”

“US economic growth fell to 2.6 percent in the fourth quarter of 2018, marking the third straight quarter in which officials reported a decline,” the outlet noted.

Conservative media outlet Townhall ran a column from Guy Benson entitled, “‘Magic Wand:’ US Economy Tops Three Percent Growth Over Calendar Year, a Milestone Obama Never Achieved.”

That’s true …


Former president Barack Obama – who once claimed Trump would need a “magic wand” to hit his economic targets – was the first U.S. chief executive since Herbert Hoover who failed to preside over at least one year in which the U.S. economy expanded at a rate of three percent or higher.

But depending on the metric you use, Trump may not have hit that number either. And his chances of hitting it could diminish further if there is a downward revision to the fourth quarter data (which seems likely given dismal December 2018 retail data).

The outlook for 2019 also remains murky. The latest data from the University of Michigan’s index of consumer sentiment revealed that twenty-five percent of all consumers reported worsening finances last month, the highest reading of the Trump presidency. Furthermore the “current conditions” index clocked in at its lowest reading since November of 2016.

Just yesterday, IHS Markit’s U.S. Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) plunged to its lowest reading in eighteen months – with new orders falling to a twenty-month lows.

“Expectations of future growth (are) running at one of the most subdued levels seen for over two years and suggesting downside risks prevail for coming months,” the firm noted.

Finally, the BEA released December and January personal income data (.pdf) on Friday – along with outlays for December.  The data, according to Zero Hedge, was “a bloodbath.”  January income fell by 0.1 percent (against expectations of a 0.3 percent uptick) while personal consumption fell 0.5 percent in December – the worst reading since September of 2009.

Once again … the economic remains on a “razor’s edge.”



Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our stories? Please feel free to submit your own guest column or letter to the editor via-email HERE. Got a tip for us? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question or a glitch to report? CLICK HERE. Want to support what we’re doing? SUBSCRIBE HERE.

Banner: Getty

Related posts


Apparel Firm Founded In South Carolina Files For Bankruptcy

Erin Parrott

Google Is Full Of It On ‘Climate Action’

Will Folks

‘Chaos In The Cabin’: Dreamliner Diverted

Will Folks

Leave a Comment