“Should I say or should I go?”
Sadly, we are not talking about the iconic 1981 punk rock anthem from The Clash. Today we are referring to people debating whether to evacuate in the face of a looming natural disaster like Hurricane Florence – which is currently stalking the east coast/ generating the sort of end-of-times headlines typically reserved for meteor strikes.
In the immortal words of Dr. Peter Venkman (a.k.a. Bill Murray) in the iconic 1984 hit Ghostbusters, “dogs and cats, living together … mass hysteria!”
In South Carolina, governor Henry McMaster ordered a million people to leave their homes yesterday. Few listened. Meanwhile in North Carolina – where local governments typically handle evacuations – governor Roy Cooper took the unprecedented step of issuing a state-level evacuation for the Outer Banks and other coastal regions of the Tar Heel State.
Both leaders made it abundantly clear that “Danger, Will Robinson” lay ahead. Did citizens heed their orders, though? For the most part, no …
(Click to view)
Those living in affected areas are far more likely to follow forecasts showing the path of the storm. If the system appears to be tracking toward them – and seems sufficiently dangerous – they will go. If not, they will stay.
Also, it is important to remember some people will never evacuate under any circumstances. Mandatory, schmandatory.
Believe it or not, there is plenty of research on the psychology of evacuations … including precisely what mental machinations prompt people to make the potentially life-or-death decision to stay or go. A common theme? During times of crisis, people need to feel as though they have control – that their decision is going to have a positive impact on their outcomes.
Of course the researchers found that “two of every five people identified a reason that would stop them evacuating.”
“The most commonly reported barrier was not knowing where to go,” they noted. “A smaller proportion reported disability or mobility issues that limited their capacity to evacuate quickly. This is particularly important for older people, families with young children, and residents of high-rise buildings. Others were concerned about theft and looting should they leave their homes.”
Oh, and let’s not forget about pets. In 2011, a poll released by the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) revealed that “nearly half of dog owners (45 percent) and cat owners (42 percent) don’t know what they would do with their pets in an evacuation, compared to less than one-third of dog owners (28 percent) and cat owners (30 percent) in the South, where hurricanes are most common.”
Timing matters, too.
According to 2010 study by Dr. Harrie C.M. Vorst, there are three phases associated with disaster evacuations – pre-impact, impact and post-impact (a.k.a. recoil). Each phase has its own set of challenges that create barriers to evacuating.
“During the pre-impact phase risk estimation is very low, so evacuation is not seen as an inevitable action,” Vorst wrote. “Heavy stress and denial of life-threatening events during the impact phase will hinder effective evacuation. Inactivity, apathy and childlike dependency on other people during the recoil stage will restrain survivors from active evacuation.”
Vorst concluded that “evacuation models will be more effective if phases and accompanying human behavior are taken into account.”
One other factor worth noting? It appears as though designating an evacuation as “mandatory” has a slight impact on participation. According to a 2010 study published in the Journal of Transportation Engineering, mandatory evacuations increase participation by around six percent compared to voluntary evacuations, which increase participation by roughly four percent.
That study used data from Hurricane Ivan, a 2004 storm that ranks as the eighth-costliest tropical system in American history.
WANNA SOUND OFF?
Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our stories? Please feel free to submit your own guest column or letter to the editor via-email HERE. Got a tip for us? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question or a glitch to report? CLICK HERE. Want to support what we’re doing? SUBSCRIBE HERE.