More SC Judicial Screening Drama

Rock Hill lawyer dismissed after violating prohibition against political activity by judicial candidates …

A candidate for a vacant South Carolina circuit court seat was disqualified from contention after participating in forbidden political activity.

Jimbo Morton of Rock Hill, S.C. – who just last month was listed as a finalist for a vacant seat in the S.C. sixteenth judicial circuit – was not screened out by a legislatively controlled panel this month.

What happened?

Members of the S.C. Judicial Merit Selection Commission (SCJMSC) were anonymously alerted to Morton’s co-sponsorship of a fundraiser for liberal U.S. congressional candidate Archie Parnell – who nearly upset U.S. congressman Ralph Norman in this spring’s special election for the South Carolina fifth congressional district.

Parnell is seeking the Democratic nomination for this seat again in next spring’s partisan primary elections.

Morton was initially found qualified to stand for legislative election, but members of the committee called him back after learning of his involvement with the Parnell campaign.

Once prospective judicial nominees submit their applications to this panel, they are no longer allowed to participate in political activities.  In other words, they are held to the same standard as sitting judges.

Morton – the former chairman of the York County Democratic party – flagrantly violated this prohibition.  Not only that, he declined to withdraw from the race when given the opportunity to do so.

So, panelists removed him.

“Just a boneheaded move from a guy who ought to know better,” a source familiar with the situation told us.

Rock Hill, S.C. prosecutor Lisa Collins, York County public defender B.J. Barrowclough and York County prosector Bill McKinnon are now the finalists in the race to replace retiring circuit court judge John C. Hayes III.

The legislative election for this seat will be held on February 7.  Candidates will be allowed to solicit commitments from lawmakers beginning on January 16.

The winner will serve a six-year term.

News of Morton’s drama – which was first reported by Andrew Dys of The Rock Hill Herald – comes just days after a ten-year veteran of the bench withdrew her name from consideration for a Lowcountry circuit court seat.

Judge Kristi Harrington announced her intention to step down from the ninth judicial circuit after numerous attorneys complained (anonymously) about her “temperament.”

This news site has consistently argued that the state’s executive branch – i.e., the governor – should appoint judges with the advise and consent of the legislature.  South Carolina’s judiciary needs to be independent – and that’s never going to happen so long as the legislative branch of government controls every facet of the appointment process.

As we reiterated earlier this year, “from the selection of judicial candidates by a committee packed with lawmakers to the actual legislative voting on their ‘merits’ – the entire system is rigged and needs to be replaced.”

Having said that, we are shocked by Morton’s stupidity.  And by his arrogance in refusing to take responsibility for his actions.

Whichever form of judicial selection you support (legislative, executive or popular election), candidates for these positions must eschew all political involvement once they indicate their intention to seek judgeships.



Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our stories? Please feel free to submit your own guest column or letter to the editor via-email HERE. Got a tip for us? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question? CLICK HERE. Want to support what we’re doing? SUBSCRIBE HERE.

Banner: iStock

Related posts


Tropics Watch: Disturbance Off Florida Coast

Will Folks

South Carolina Islanders Brace For Luxury ‘EcoTourism’ Development

Callie Lyons

Pastor John-Paul Miller’s Personality Test: Mining for Clues

Callie Lyons

Leave a Comment