You can’t cut taxes during an economic downturn, can you? At a time when revenues to government are uncertain/ unstable, you cannot possibly implement policies that could potentially reduce them, right?
Obviously conventional thinking (i.e. big government “wisdom”) dictates that shortfalls in revenue must be met with tax increases – or at the very least, revenue neutrality.
However, we believe such thinking is counterintuitive.
As South Carolina braces for the economic impact of the next round of the coronavirus pandemic, we believe a compelling case can be made to reduce taxes – and in particular, the Palmetto State’s onerous top marginal income tax rate.
Maybe they will, but …
Assuming anyone has the stones to offer an income tax cut, we predict these “leaders” will reject it on the argument that the state cannot afford to cut taxes. Of course, this reflexive rejection of tax relief neglects to acknowledge that South Carolina currently subsidizes a ton of things it shouldn’t (see here, here and here) – and that cutting taxes actually has a stimulative effect on the economy that can wind up raising revenues for government.
But these are familiar arguments … which our news outlet has been making for years.
We have also argued for years that the Palmetto State is simply not competitive when it comes to its income tax rate.
As you can see from the chart below (published by the Tax Foundation), South Carolina has the highest top marginal income tax rate in the southeast. In fact, it has the 11th highest income tax rate in the entire country.
Meanwhile, seven states (including our regional competitor, Florida) do not levy an income tax at all ….
(Click to view)
The punitive nature of South Carolina’s exorbitantly high tax rate is exacerbated by the fact that its top marginal seven percent levy kicks in on all income over $15,400 – which makes it regressive in addition to being anti-competitive.
Again, though … we have been making these arguments for years. Just as we have argued repeatedly that cutting income taxes will have a profoundly positive impact on the small businesses which drive employment growth (and income growth) in South Carolina.
This time, there is another factor to consider as the Palmetto State enters an incredibly uncertain economic climate in 2021.
And for once, our state is well-positioned from a competitive standpoint … assuming it chooses wisely.
Back in September, University of South Carolina economist Joseph Von Nessen addressed the school’s fortieth annual economic outlook series and offered some interesting thoughts on the Covid-19 economy.
Specifically, he addressed the extent to which the evolving American workplace presented the Palmetto State with an opportunity to change its traditional approach to recruiting jobs.
“To the extent that the work-from-home phenomenon becomes a permanent part of the business landscape, South Carolina will have to begin re-thinking its approach to economic development,” Von Nessen said, according to reporter Jessica Holdman of The (Charleston, S.C.) Post and Courier. “Economic development may become as much about persuading workers to live in South Carolina and telecommute as it is about direct company recruitment.”
Von Nessen and fellow South Carolina professor Douglas Woodward argued that the flight of citizens from larger cities – whether attributable to rising urban violence or unsustainable costs of living – presented the Palmetto State with a golden recruitment opportunity.
“I think this is permanent,” Woodward said, according to Holdman’s report. “All of a sudden South Carolina is a very attractive place to live and work.”
Is it, though?
Certainly, it could be … assuming leaders in the S.C. General Assembly (and McMaster) were ever to undertake a concerted effort to embrace competitiveness rather than cronyism.
You know, targeting resources where they will actually produce positive results rather than perpetuating a failed status quo year after year after year …
Imagine that, right? Imagine what our state could accomplish?
Over the next few weeks, this news outlet will be laying out precisely such an agenda for lawmakers to consider as they approach the 2021 legislative session – and you can bet that individual income tax relief will be at the very top of that list.
Which, again, will make our agenda radically different than the agenda of the “business community.”
Given its natural beauty, temperate climate and comparatively low cost of living, South Carolina is uniquely positioned to capitalize on the economic trends settling across the national landscape in the aftermath of the Covid-19 pandemic.
But doing so successfully will require forward thinking and a willingness to challenge the status quo … two commodities that have been in chronically short supply in the corridors of power in Columbia, S.C.
Stay tuned for our specific income tax proposal as well as other items from our 2021 agenda in the days to come …
WANNA SOUND OFF
Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our stories? Or an issue you’d like to address proactively? We have an open microphone policy here at FITSNews! Submit your own letter to the editor (or guest column) via-email HERE. Got a tip for a story? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question or a glitch to report? CLICK HERE.