Image default
STATE HOUSE

Yet Another South Carolina Judicial Selection Scandal

‘Burn book’ drama is no way to pick your judges, South Carolina…

by WILL FOLKS

***

If recent South Carolina history has taught us anything, it’s that the Palmetto State’s notoriously self-serving clique of powerful lawyer-legislators – which profits handsomely from its control of the selection and election of judges statewide – is utterly incapable of faithfully discharging this obligation.

Every year, some new and more viral strain of institutional corruption, political intrigue or personal indiscretion infects the “integrity” of this legislatively controlled process. And every year, the resulting scandal reminds South Carolinians of just how desperately real judicial selection reform is needed, just how long it is overdue and just how unwilling lawmakers are to effectuate it.

South Carolina is one of only two states in America where lawmakers elect judges – and the only one in which the selection process preceding these elections is controlled exclusively by the legislative branch. In addition to being inherently unethical, this process has shredded the Palmetto State’s separation of powers, destroyed the independence and integrity of its judicial branch and materially eroded the safety of the public.

This year is no different… and no, I’m not referring to the fact lawmakers just threw a sitting supreme court justice off the bench for having the audacity to accurately interpret the law. Or that Republican lawmakers – who are facing sustained public pressure on this issue – continue to focus on the illusion of fixing the problem as opposed to actually fixing it.

This year’s scandal is yet another glaring indictment of the selection process itself…

Support FITSNews … SUBSCRIBE!

***

South Carolina’s Judicial Merit Selection Commission (JMSC) – the legislatively dominated panel that currently picks which judges are allowed to stand for legislative election – descended into middle school chaos this week when four candidates for a circuit court judgeship in the Palmetto Upstate were all deemed “not qualified.” These determinations were reached after it was alleged that judicial “ballot box” surveys – or questionnaires purportedly used by committee members to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the candidates during the screening process – had been improperly “manipulated” by individuals with a stake in the outcome of the race.

Specifically, the ballot box in the tenth circuit race was allegedly manipulated “in an advocacy manner” to impugn the integrity of one of the candidates – with one candidate and their spouse allegedly having “solicited negative comments” against the candidate in question.

Not only that, one of the four candidates identified the husband of one of his opponents in connection with the allegations.

That’s right…

***

***

“It’s my understanding from some things that have been communicated to me that people have done that to me,” Oconee County chief magistrate judge Andrew Holliday told the panel, citing rumors which implicated a rival candidate as well as “their spouse and several colleagues.”

The candidate in question, Lindsey Satterfield Simmons, is the chief judge and director of Clemson University’s municipal court. She was accused alongside her husband, Upstate attorney and former magistrate judge Todd Simmons, of stuffing the ballot box with negative comments against Holliday.

Questioned by the panel, Simmons denied attempting to manipulate the process – and denied having any knowledge of anyone attempting to do so on her behalf.

While commissioners wrung their hands in righteous indignation – and spoke of such manipulation being a “disqualifying event” – the reality is their own secretive, juvenile selection process is a huge part of the problem. Seriously, who believed creating an anonymous forum dedicated to the fomentation of sour grapes, self-interested score-settling, petty grudges and personal vendettas would wind up yielding anything resembling creditable intelligence?

That’s exactly the format the JMSC has created, though…

***

South Carolina State House
RELATED | THE WAR FOR JUSTICE

***

“The commission shall conduct an anonymous survey of the bench and bar and all clerks of court in South Carolina,” the JMSC’s recently updated guidelines (.pdf) noted. “The commission shall utilize an electronic survey polling or other forms of electronic survey as it deems appropriate.”

Those filling out these electronic surveys are assured their responses “will be kept strictly confidential,” but if there are investigations or lawsuits tied to this drama our guess is that assurance will go out the window pretty quickly.

In other words, it’s a veritable “burn book” for disgruntled attorneys, judges and court officials with spleens to vent and axes to grind – just the sort of backroom grist befitting such a contemptibly opaque selection method. It’s also a convenient method of generating faux scandal misdirection in the hopes of removing certain candidates – or slates of candidates – under false pretenses so that lawmakers can install the judges they really want.

Compounding the corruptibility of the current process, individual JMSC members – who control the flow of information ultimately released from these anonymous surveys – are expressly allowed by their own rules to participate in them. The commission’s rules explicitly permit commissioners to fill out anonymous surveys “wherein the member’s personal opinions about judicial candidates are solicited.” Meaning they can throw punches privately… then revel in the public chaos those punches create. All without anyone being the wiser.

Is there a better way than this? Hell yes…

Since early 2023 we have endorsed a hybrid model – one in which governors appoint judicial nominees, lawmakers confirm them and the public votes on them every two years via “aye” or “nay” retention elections. Such a model would equitably establish the balance of power between our three branches of government, retain legislative oversight of the selection process and – perhaps most importantly – inject a desperately needed element of direct public accountability into the mix.

Every year, South Carolina’s current judicial selection system provides us with fresh evidence of its unfitness for the job. It is past time we throw it out and start over with a system built on true accountability – not secrets, favors, shadows and lies.

***

ABOUT THE AUTHOR…

Will Folks (Andrew Fancher/ FITSNews)

Will Folks is the founding editor of the news outlet you are currently reading. Prior to founding FITSNews, he served as press secretary to the governor of South Carolina. He lives in the Midlands region of the state with his wife and eight children.

***

SOUND OFF…

Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our articles? Or an issue you’d like to address proactively? We have an open microphone policy! Submit your letter to the editor (or guest column) via email HERE. Got a tip for a story? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question or a glitch to report? CLICK HERE.

***

Subscribe to our newsletter by clicking here…

*****

Related posts

POLITICS

2026 Election Sparks Panic at the S.C. State House

Will Folks
STATE HOUSE

Alan Wilson Transition Takes First Steps Toward Creating a New Cabinet

Will Folks
BUSINESS

Another S.C. Senator Pushes Lawsuit Reform

FITSNews

Leave a Comment