CRIME & COURTS

Susan Smith Denied Parole a Second Time

Notorious South Carolina killer will continue serving two life sentences for the 1994 murders of her young sons…

by JENN WOOD

***

South Carolina’s parole board denied convicted killer Susan Smith latest bid for freedom on Thursday (November 19, 2026) – ensuring she will remain behind bars more than three decades after she drowned her two young sons in a Union County lake.

As it wa, this week’s vote was unanimous among participating parole board members. Board member Geraldine Miro once again recused herself because she previously served as acting warden at a prison where Smith was once housed.

Smith, 55, is serving two life sentences for the murders of three-year-old Michael Smith and 14-month-old Alex Smith. She first became eligible for parole in 2024 after serving 30 years.

On October 25, 1994, Smith strapped her two young boys into their carseats in the back of her burgundy Mazda sedan – and proceeded to let the vehicle roll down a boat ramp into the John D. Long Lake five miles northeast of her hometown of Union, S.C. Smith later told police a black man had carjacked her at a stoplight in Union – at gunpoint – and driven away with her children still inside the vehicle.

(Click to view)

***

As the search for the boys drew national attention, Smith went on television with her husband, David Smith, to plead for the children’s safe return.

“I wanna say to my babies that your momma loves you so much,” Smith tearfully told reporters at one press conference. “You gotta be strong… I just know, I just feel in my heart that you’re okay. You’ve just gotta take care of each other.”

Authorities doubted Smith’s carjacking story from the beginning. According to them, the Main Street intersection in Union, S.C. where she claimed to have been carjacked would not have presented her with a red light unless other vehicles were attempting to cross the intersecting roadway at the same time. Smith claimed no other vehicles were present at the time of the carjacking – meaning the light wouldn’t have turned red for her.

Aware that Smith was likely lying to them, police began almost immediately to suspect her involvement in the disappearance of her children. In fact, they actually searched the lake where the boys’ bodies were eventually found – but were unable to locate the vehicle right away because it came to rest significantly further from shore than they originally suspected.

On November 3, 1994 she confessed to killing her two young sons.

Support FITSNews … SUBSCRIBE!

***

‘For Me, It’s Yesterday’

In an emotional statement, David Smith told the board that granting his former wife parole would be a profound injustice to Michael and Alex.

“Thirty-two years is a long time, but for me, it’s yesterday,” he said.

David told the board he came to speak for his sons. He asked board members to consider whether 32 years was enough for what Susan had done to Michael and Alex. His wife, Tiffany Smith, and their daughter, Savannah Smith, also urged the board to keep her in prison. Savannah said she never met her brothers but had grown up seeing what their loss had done to her family. She spoke about how they should be there for birthdays, holidays and the milestones in between.

Former S.C. sixteenth circuit solicitor Tommy Pope, who prosecuted Smith, told the board that returning for parole hearings was, in some ways, harder on the family than the trial. He called David his “rock” during the prosecution and said Smith should spend the rest of her life in prison.

Kevin Brackett, the current sixteenth circuit solicitor who worked on the case with Pope, also opposed release. He reminded the board that before Smith’s first hearing, she had been in touch with someone in the media about telling her story. Brackett told the board he feared Smith would try to profit from the case if released.

***

Smith appeared by video from Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood. She apologized to her sons, to David and to the people who loved the boys. She told the board she knew David had missed seeing Michael and Alex learn to ride a bike and go to school.

“They were innocent children,” Smith said. “They did not deserve to die.”

Smith said she had changed in the past thirty-two years and wanted to help others and honor her sons’ memory. She disputed the prosecution’s account that she killed the boys because of a relationship with another man.

Her attorney, Tommy Thomas, argued untreated mental health problems were central to what happened in 1994. He pointed to programs Smith had completed in prison and outlined a release plan that included transitional housing at Soteria House, employment assistance and outpatient mental health care. A forensic psychiatrist who evaluated Smith for the defense discussed her childhood trauma, depression and what the psychiatrist described as sustained improvement since around 2015.

***

RELATED | Tommy Pope Recalls The Prosecution Of Susan Smith

***

Why Tommy Pope Sought The Death Penalty

At trial, prosecutors argued Smith killed her sons because she wanted to pursue a relationship with a man who had told her he did not want children. Her defense attributed her actions to mental health problems and said she had planned to die with the boys before backing out.

In a March 2024 interview with FITSNews, Pope recalled being in the middle of an unrelated trial when a state agent called to tell him Smith had confessed. Pope drove to Union County and was at the lake when crews pulled the Mazda from the water. Michael and Alex were still strapped into their car seats.

Pope also recalled how difficult it was to prosecute the case in a town where so many people knew the family. The sheriff was Susan Smith’s godfather, and some witnesses Pope would ordinarily have counted on opposed his decision to seek the death penalty.

David Smith, he said, stood by him on that decision.

Pope told FITSNews he asked himself what the public would have expected if the carjacker Smith described had been real, or if the boys’ father had killed them. In either case, he said, the public would have demanded that he seek the death penalty.

“I just felt that whatever the maximum penalty was, I felt that she deserved that,” Pope said.

The jury found Smith guilty of both murders in July 1995 after about two hours of deliberations. The same jury declined to sentence her to death. Pope told FITSNews he considered the prosecution unsuccessful because the jury spared her life. He later opposed her release at the 2024 parole hearing.

***

What The Board Heard In 2024

At Smith’s first parole hearing on November 20, 2024, the board voted 5–0 to deny her release, citing the seriousness of the murders and her prison disciplinary record. Geraldine Miro also recused herself at that hearing. Smith apologized for killing her sons, and David Smith urged the board to keep her in prison.

As FITSNews reported ahead of that hearing, the board weighs an inmate’s conduct in prison alongside the seriousness of the crime, victim input and plans for release. Months before that hearing, prison officials suspended Smith’s phone, canteen and tablet entertainment privileges for 90 days after she communicated with a documentary filmmaker about the case. FITSNews obtained messages related to the project through a public records request.

***

What Happens Next

Smith’s case is due for another parole review in 2028 under South Carolina’s two-year review schedule. Michael and Alex’s family will again have the opportunity to tell the board what her release would mean to them.

Pope, who now serves in the S.C. House, told the board he would look for a way to lengthen the time between parole reviews. He floated intervals of three, four or five years and pointed to the toll the hearings take on Michael and Alex’s family.

Tiffany Smith told the board Thursday what coming back every two years has meant for the family.

“Every time we must come before this board, it forces us to reopen wounds that never really healed,” she said. “We must revisit the worst tragedy of our lives, and once again ask that the person responsible remain in prison.”

***

ABOUT THE AUTHOR …

Jenn Wood (Provided)

As a private investigator turned journalist, Jenn Wood brings a unique skill set to FITSNews as its research director. Known for her meticulous sourcing and victim-centered approach, she helps shape the newsroom’s most complex investigative stories while producing the FITSFiles and Cheer Incorporated podcasts. Jenn lives in South Carolina with her family, where her work continues to spotlight truth, accountability, and justice.

***

SOUND OFF…

Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our articles? Or an issue you’d like to address proactively? We have an open microphone policy! Submit your letter to the editor (or guest column) via email HERE. Got a tip for a story? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question or a glitch to report? CLICK HERE.

***

Subscribe to our newsletter by clicking here…

*****

Related posts

CRIME & COURTS

How Spartanburg County Caught on to the Ex-Sheriff’s ‘No-Show’ Cousin

Andrew Fancher
CRIME & COURTS

FBI ‘Most Wanted’ Medicare Fraudster Sentenced To 20 Years

Erin Parrott
CRIME & COURTS

Unsolved Carolinas: What Happened To Libby Crawford?

Jenn Wood

Leave a Comment