CRIME & COURTS

Becky Hill Lawsuit: Murdaugh Takes Fight To Appeals Court

Attorneys argue jury interference destroyed the value of Murdaugh’s $600,000 defense — and that a federal judge dismissed the case on the wrong grounds…

by JENN WOOD *** Amid an avalanche of filings tied to his double homicide retrial, attorneys f
You must Subscribe or log in to read the rest of this content.

Related posts

CRIME & COURTS

Dirty Water, Falsified Records: Guilty Plea In Saluda Pollution Case

Jenn Wood
CRIME & COURTS

Ladson Tragedy: Father Asks Judge to Order Sheriff to Turn Over Records

Jenn Wood
CRIME & COURTS

Search Underway For Missing South Carolina Infant (UPDATED)

Erin Parrott

2 comments

SubZeroIQ October 11, 2026 at 9:38 am

This little-noticed first-trial OFFICIAL trial transcript should put to rest the FALSE claim that Alex lied about being at the kennels. He just did not volunteer the details:
The Prosecution does NOT want to test the male DNA in the swab from Maggie’s phone because it knows that, like the DNA from Maggie’s fingernails, it will EXCLUDE Alex because Alex NEVER had Maggie’s phone that night and was eager to help the responders on the scene find it the next morning.
Besides, Alex NEVER ever actually said “I was never at the kennels” or ANYTHING like that. TO THE CONTRARY, when Rogan Gibson told “Grandmar” (Maggie’s mother) that he heard Alex’s voice in the background of the phone conversation with Paul which preceded the unsent video, Alex WAS in the room with Rogan Gibson and Grandmar but did NOT “stand up and say no I wasn’t there.”
Here is the trial transcript, with page and line numbers, from the OFFICIAL Record on Appeal (RoA):

[RoA_2669, line 25] Q. 172. Is that another screen shot of your phone?
(R. GIBSON – DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. WATERS [Transcript page 1437 = RoA_2670])
[1] A. It is.
[2] Q. And are those other missed calls that came in?
[3] A. 10:25 p.m. and 10:30 p.m.
[4-6] Q. When you spoke to Special Agent Croft on June 8th of 2021, did you tell him and Special Agent McCallister who you thought you heard on that phone call at 8:40?
[7] A. I did.
[8] Q. And who did you say you heard?
[9] A. I thought it was Mr. Alex but I wasn’t exactly sure.
[10] Q. And did you give him a percentage?
[11] A. I did.
[12] Q. What did you say?
[13] A. 99 percent.
[14] Q. That you heard Mr. Alex on that phone call at 8:40.
[15] A. That’s correct.
[16-17] Q. As time went on after the murders, did you go to Moselle where all of the family and friends were gathering?
[18] A. I did.
[19] Q. Were you there a fair amount?
[20-21] A. Probably the whole part of that — or that — later that week.
[22-24] Q. While you were there at the house where the family and friends had gathered, did anyone ever ask you about your last contact with Paul?
[25] A. There was.
(R. GIBSON – DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. WATERS [RoA_2671 = 1438])
[1] Q. And who asked you?
[2] A. Grandmar.
[3] Q. And that would be Ms. Branstetter?
[4] A. That’s correct.
[5] Q. Maggie’s mother?
[6] A. That’s correct.
[7] Q. And what did you say?
[8-10] A. I told her, yeah, that I had talked to Paul about the dog. I told her that I heard Ms. Maggie in the background, and I heard a male voice that I thought was Mr. Alex.
[11] Q. Was he in the room then?
[12] A. Yes.
[13] Q. Did he stand up and say no, I wasn’t there?
[14] A. He didn’t.
[15-16] Q. Did you ever have any conversation with Alex Murdaugh about what happened that night?
[17] A. No, sir.
[18-19] Q. Did he ever ask you about whether or not you heard him on that phone that night?
[20] A. No, sir.
[21] Q. Did he ever tell you what he did that night?
[22] A. No, sir.
[23] Q. Did you ever ask him what he did that night?
[24] A. No, sir.

Reply
SubZeroIQ October 14, 2026 at 12:58 pm

Urgent VIC:
What did Judge Debra McCaslin order just this morning?
Why aren’t you all asking for the clerk to scan the filings in Murdaugh’s criminal case to the public index as they do, or are supposed to do, in all civil circuit court cases?
The primitive technology it there. All they have to do is scan the papers in the same scanning machine they use for civil cases. And, of course in both civil and criminal cases, the judges retains the sound discretion to order a document sealed.
For ones clamoring for the release of the Ravanel-Dennis files (on which I have no opinion other than that my true church allows neither divorce nor extra-marital carnal knowledge), you are strangely silent on the PUBLIC Murdaugh filings not being immediately visible to the public.

Reply

Leave a Comment