by TOM DAVIS
***
South Carolina leads the nation in drunk driving deaths. According to NHTSA estimates, our state had the country’s highest alcohol-impaired fatality rate in both 2022 and 2023. In 2022, about 43 percent of South Carolina’s traffic deaths involved an impaired driver. The national figure was 32 percent.
Behind those numbers are people like Samantha Miller. She was leaving her wedding reception at Folly Beach, S.C. in a golf cart when a driver hit them from behind. The driver was three times the legal limit and going sixty-five miles per hour in a 25 mile-per-hour zone. Miller died at the scene, still in her wedding dress.
Rural roads are part of the story. The part we control is the law – and our law has a problem that tougher sentences alone won’t fix. Too many DUI cases fall apart before anyone is convicted.
***
RELATED | A PERFECT DAY ENDS IN TRAGEDY
***
Look at how the system works today. For many defendants, refusing a breath test is the smart move. Whole cases are dismissed because of technical problems with the arrest video. Charges are routinely pled down several levels, and first offenders keep driving without an ignition interlock while their cases are pending. Deterrence depends on the certainty of consequences, and South Carolina hasn’t had enough of it.
That’s why I wrote S. 52. It paired tougher penalties with the reforms that turn penalties into convictions. Before a DUI charge could be pled down, a judge would have to find compelling reasons on the record. Every county would have dedicated, solicitor-led DUI prosecution. The bill repealed the presumption that a driver at 0.05 is not impaired. A video failure would lead to suppressing that evidence, not dismissing the whole case. The bill also set a workable standard for blood testing and required an interlock for every offender while a case is pending. It did all of that while keeping every protection the accused has under current law.

***
The Senate passed S. 52 unanimously in February. The House kept the tougher penalties but removed the enforcement provisions. In June, a conference report put back some of them in weakened form. The plea limit no longer required a judge’s finding. Dedicated prosecution became a six-county pilot that would start only once it was funded. The 0.05 presumption and video dismissals stayed in place. The report also added significant new policy, including DUI expungement and a THC offense, that neither chamber had debated. Adopting it would have required free conference powers, and the Senate refused them.
I was disappointed, most of all for the families who came to Columbia to testify. But a hollow bill would have let everyone declare the problem solved when it wasn’t. Tougher sentences that fewer people actually receive aren’t reform.
So on December 15, I will prefile the bill again for the 2027 session. Its core will be the same, because the core is what saves lives. I’ve also listened to last year’s debate, and the new bill will include the good ideas that came out of the House and the conference committee.
***
RELATED | DUI REFORM BILL IS BACK ON THE TABLE FOR 2027
***
I’m changing how we get there, too. Last year the two chambers worked out their differences at the very end, in conference, with a deadline looming. This year I intend to do that work first.
Before session begins, I’ll sit down with House members, solicitors, and law enforcement to find common ground on the enforcement provisions. When the bill reaches the House floor, both chambers should already understand it and be able to support it.
Every member of the General Assembly wants fewer South Carolinians to die on our roads. We agree on the goal. In 2027, let’s pass a law that actually reaches it.
***
ABOUT THE AUTHOR…

Tom Davis represents South Carolina Senate District 46, which covers Beaufort and Jasper counties.
***
SOUND OFF…
Got something you’d like to say in response to one of our articles? Or an issue you’d like to address proactively? We have an open microphone policy! Submit your letter to the editor (or guest column) via email HERE. Got a tip for a story? CLICK HERE. Got a technical question or a glitch to report? CLICK HERE.



