Innovista Implosion Accelerates
Last week’s decision by the U.S. Department of Energy to zero out hydrogen fuel cell research was a dagger in the heart of S.C. House Speaker Bobby Harrell’s vision of government-dominated economic development in the Palmetto State.
It may have also dealt the final, fatal blow to the University of South Carolina’s costly “Innovista” research campus – which was supposed to be ground zero for the “hydrogen economy” that Harrell, Columbia mayor Bob Coble and USC President Harris Pastides (above) promised would bring our state millions of dollars in new capital investment.
Oh, and thousands of new jobs.
In fact, Pastides was elevated to the USC Presidency by liberal philanthropist Darla Moore and disgraced Carolina First CEO Mack Whittle specifically to see Innovista through.
Yet even before DOE’s announcement, Innovista was already falling apart – having failed miserably to leverage the millions of taxpayer dollars being poured into it.
Specifically, the campus has been unable to close the loan on its “Horizon II” building, which is where the public-private partnerships were supposed to be housed.
Without that loan, the entire Research University Infrastructure Act state bonding for the project comes crashing down.
In spite of this, the City of Columbia and Richland County are both contributing more than $30 million to fund two new parking garages adjacent to each of Innovista’s “signature research blocks,” the “Horizon Center” and “Discovery Plaza.”
Should they be making such an investment? Particularly now?
The “Horizon II” facilities are obviously in danger of never being built, whereas the “Horizon I” facilities still need an additional $20 million before they are operational.
Where will the money come from?
Clearly the private sector isn’t coughing it up. The state doesn’t have it. And now, even Barack Obama’s Energy Department is refusing to pick up the tab.
Interestingly enough, a $12.5 million Energy Department grant that was secured earlier this year by USC is for research that’s supposed to be conducted in “Horizon I” building, which is currently just a shell.
In other words, USC lacks the facilities to conduct the research the feds are funding.
Did DOE bother to check that out before awarding the grant?
Other buildings on this $140 million campus are also not what they appear to be.
For example, the “Discovery I” campus houses two University groups on its first two floors, while the top three floors are empty and will require another $20 million in funding to complete.
So who, exactly, are Innovista’s tenants?
Well, other than USC’s own School of Public Health, the pickings are pretty slim.
There’s Collexis, a small local firm with extensive USC connections, and then there’s the Loccioni Group, an Italian firm specializing in precision measurement technology.
That’s it. Two firms. A handful of employees.
The other prospective tenants are tied up in “University partnerships” which depend on a mixture of federal funding, state funding and state bond issues to successfully pull off.
Needless to say, pulling anything off at this campus just got a lot harder, which brings us back to the fundamental danger of government trying to pick winners and losers in the private sector – with your money.
Stay tuned … we’re just getting warmed up on this massive waste of taxpayer dollars …






Comments
By hammerheadSC on May 12th, 2009 at 3:17 pm
This should knock a few people out of office. When are politicians, university administration and government officials going to learn the old saying, don’t count your chickens before they hatch. Would love to see how much finishing this project is going to cost taxpayers.
By John on May 12th, 2009 at 3:43 pm
I agree with your view on the government picking winners and losers, but are you saying the main reason Harris Pastides was selected as the president was this project? I doubt that is a fair characterization of the selection process. I have no doubt Dr. Pastides deserves his share of criticism, but attacking his legitimacy for his job (without specific proof) is a little much.
By Just a thought on May 12th, 2009 at 6:12 pm
again, this is reminding me of holderman
By Anne on May 12th, 2009 at 7:27 pm
Not sure what you’re talking about…according to The State, Innovista is already a lot more than small local firms with “a handful of employees.” IBM, Blue Cross Blue Shield, TM Floyd, VC3 and others have all signed on as part of the Consortium for Enterprise Management at Innovista.TM Floyd and VC3 employ over 100 people. BCBS is helping finance the consortium and IBM has committed to providing its System z mainframe computer and software. Sounds to me like these big-name companies wouldn’t be committing to Innovista if they didn’t see it as being viable and/or having the ability to serve as a location for a successful computer training program.
By fitsnews on May 12th, 2009 at 7:54 pm
Anne-
Nice try. All those companies HAVE signed on for the University-sponsored “consortium,” but if you actually read the article you’d see that they CAN’T GET THE LOAN FOR THE BUILDING.
Without the loan there’s no RUIA bonding, no building and no consortium.
-FITS
By Liberty For Me on May 12th, 2009 at 10:53 pm
I think hydrogen is the future energy source we need to perfect…But I dont want my tax money going to something that should be privitly funded.This is not what government is for.I would encourage tax breaks for people to invest in R&D.What is it politicians dont get about their place in the constitution?…and yes the same goes for local gov as well.
If there is extra money for that kind of waste,then give it back to the taxpayers to start jobs and repair the economy
By craig on May 12th, 2009 at 11:31 pm
Carolina’s fossils on the BOT should be fired for the lame brained decision to hire Pastides instead of Andy Card.
By Josh on May 13th, 2009 at 6:25 am
I think you are trying to make a mountain out of a mole hill with uniformed information. Article after article in reputable newspapers have identified stationary and portable fuel cells as the focus in the Columbia region. Existing uses like cell phone towers, portable power for emergency responders, cell phone batteries, forklifts and other applications are in use today. The military is accelerating its use of fuel cells with companies in South Carolina helping to lead this development. Why not tell the whole story for a change.
By My Two Cents on May 13th, 2009 at 7:47 am
I agree with Josh. Jeff Wilkinson wrote in Saturday’s State that while Obama is cutting funding for hydrogen transportation research he is still supporting the US Energy Department to continue research into stationary fuel cells for applications like batteries or backup power sources. In other words, Obama is supporting research that is and can be used NOW. And while he may be temporarily holding off research for hydrogen transportation that could take a little longer to actually be implemented, that doesn’t spell the end of Innovista or all the great research in the area of hydrogen fuel cells that is being done in our state.
By fitsnews on May 13th, 2009 at 8:05 am
Josh/ 2 Cents-
Good to see the government sector chiming in.
Of COURSE it doesn’t spell the end of Innovista – not as long as you guys keep sucking up the tax dollars, right?
-FITS
By USC Grad on May 13th, 2009 at 8:47 am
Clearly, the Pastides hire was designed to keep under wraps all the money that’s been wasted over at USC on these special “projects.”